Peer Review
- A better way to review
Why Peer Review
1. peer review can help you learn your common mistakes, then you won’t make those mistakes again
2. peer review can make your paper so much better
3. sometimes you can’t see your mistakes because you are blinded by your own work
The peer review method
What is Peer Review
- There are many different methods of peer
review but today we will discuss 4 of the many· P.Q.P
· “Elbowing procedures”
· Slice and dice
· Interactive
Methods
Praise Question Polish:
This consists of 3 parts
· Praise: you say what you thought was good about the paper or essay
· Question: what do you not understand?
· Polish: what specific suggestions do you have for improvement.
“Elbowing procedures”
· Designed by Peter Elbow this method asks questions like...
· I heard..
· i liked....
· i wondered...
· i had a question about....
· i was looking for an example of...
The slice and dice method
· Writer listens to other student read their essay or paper.
· Author takes notes on comment and revisions other students have.
· Writer revises paper or essay.
Interactive peer review
· paper is read by the writer to a group they discuss
· after the paper is discussed they decide unanimously to either accept or reject the paper
· the paper will be rejected if there is revision needed
· the paper will be accepted if there in no revision needed
Answer
these questions on a blank sheet of paper:
-What
did you learn?
- Have you already used peer review in the past?
- Will you use peer review in the future?
This below is a power point talking about peer review
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0BwUB-2IaY9XfNGtIeFk2bEk0Ykk/edit
| |
This below is a power point talking about peer review
|
No comments:
Post a Comment